X
HGG Community Forums
Log In to HorseGeneticsGame
HGG Community Forums
Join our discord server!
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Categories
- All Discussions68,241
- Announcements356
- HJ2 Discussion67,060
- ↳ New Member Introductions569
- ↳ Help me out3,469
- ↳ Horses For Sale and Auction12,515
- ↳ Breeding Ads and Sales3,456
- ↳ Herd Helper39,570
- ↳ Bug Discussion120
- ↳ Repair Log12
- General Discussion825
- ↳ Saddle Sisterhood32
- ↳ Games, Contests and GiveAWays54
- ↳ Genetics245
In this Discussion
- Cheers May 2017
- WindwardFarm May 2017
Who's Online (0)
Need to start weeding....
-
I have WAY too many stallions and colts. Almost everything I bred this season gave me a colt, and now I have too many and no good strategy formed to week them out. I like to breed for color, the flashier the better, but PT is also a good bonus if I can get it high. If it's I need to do more testing, I'll wait to start weeding out my herd until I can get the upgrade. But any helpful hints?
-
If you don't have access to Papering or Strict Breeding Advice or Comparison testing, weeding out colts is difficult. There are a few things you could combine to help you cull though.
First, a horse's PT is in no way shape or form an indication of its breeding ability. A high PT horse may have crap breeding ability and produce mostly low PT foals, while a low PT horse may have amazing breeding ability and produce high PT high breeding ability foals. PT in Breeders is only helpful when you are looking at the PT of a horse's offspring in comparison to the PT of another, similar horses offspring--comparing Average Foal PT (AFPT) is a good way of comparing breeding ability within a group of similar horses. High breeding ability horses will have a higher AFPT than lower breeding ability horses assuming that you control for things like pasture bonus and the quality of the other parent (so if you are comparing a group of mares, you should try to compare mares who have had the same pasture bonus and were bred to the same stallion, or were all bred to Perfect Foundation quality stallions, etc). If you need me to explain this more let me know.
So based on that, I would think about culling based on these factors:
Color--you say you want to breed for color, so snip anything that doesn't have the genes you want.
Consistency--consistency (or more particularly, lack thereof) is a heritable trait in this game and will show up both as inconsistent foals but also as foals with lower PTs. If you get an inconsistent foal and GMT it to be consistent, it's PT will come up! This in turn will affect its parents AFPT....so you should at least consider snipping horses that are inconsistent.
PT--now, this may sound insane, but you should consider snipping your HIGH PT extra colts. The horses with a higher PT will train longer and in theory will be better show ponies (though Showing has as least as much to do with luck as it does with a high PT) and thus will benefit more from the training bonus that snipped horses get.
All of this said, if you think you might be able to upgrade relatively soon there is nothing wrong with holding your colts intact and testing them when you get your upgrade. -
If you haven't tested all the colts with the free breeding advice, that should be the first thing you do. Next, assuming that you care about consistency, I would go through and snip all of the colts that are inconsistent. If there's one that you absolutely love and it's inconsistent, you can use 1 GMT token to make it perfectly consistent. But I wouldn't do that unless the colt is something super special that you don't think you can replace. Unless it has some limited edition genes or something similar, you will generally be able to breed a replacement at some point.
If you have a premium upgrade you can use Strict Breeding Advice to help you thin out your herd some more. It will snip any horse that has worse breeding ability than either one of its parents, whereas regular breeding advice won't snip something unless it's significantly worse than either parent. If you're like me and you only have a basic upgrade, you don't have access to SBA.
Make sure you paper all of your colts. I paper mine after I run them through breeding advice because that saves some money since you won't have to pay to paper colts that will be snipped by free testing. Personally, I always geld any 2G colts that paper C and any 3G colts that paper B, but you can have whatever quality benchmarks that you want.
If you haven't color tested yet, I'd do that now but I like to hold off on snipping or selling the ones that aren't colors I like until after I finish my ability testing. I like to do my breeding advice and papering before I snip based on color because sometimes your best colt ability wise can end up being the plain one.
The comparison testing is the last thing I do because it costs the most money. It's a big help because you choose 2 stallions to compare and it will tell you which one is the better breeder or it will say the two stallions are about as good as each other if they are pretty close in ability.
If your best colt does end up being the plainest one and you really want it to be flashy, you can use GMTs to add genes onto a lined horse if it missed getting that gene from one of its parents. All genes on lined horses only cost 1 GMT to change, even if adding that gene to a foundation horse costs a lot more. GMTs are expensive though, so make sure you are only using them on horses that are really something special. I used one to add White M back onto one of my nice colts because I really wanted to have that gene in my herd so I could take advantage of the pasture bonus and not have to use straws/public breeding. It costs 40 GMTs to put White M on a foundation so 1 GMT for a lined horse is a much better deal.